Country name 2009 2010 2011 2012
Germany 8 8 8 8
Japan 9 9 8 8
Bosnia and Herzegovina 9 9 9 9
Hungary 10 9 9 9
Liechtenstein 11 9 11 10
Italy 10 9 9 9
Singapore 10 9 10 10
Korea, Rep. 9 9 9 10
Serbia 10 9 9 9
Malta 10 9 10 10
Austria 9 9 9 9
Latvia 10 9 9 10
Macao SAR, China 9 9 10 10
Portugal 9 10 9 9
Croatia 10 10 10 10
Andorra 10 10 10
Cuba 10 10 10 10
Greece 11 10 10 9
Bulgaria 11 10 10 10
Switzerland 10 10 10 10
Spain 11 10 10 10
Romania 11 11 10 10
San Marino 11 11 10 10
Central Europe and the Baltics 11 11 10 10
Poland 11 11 10 10
Ukraine 11 11 11 11
Aruba 11 11 11 10
Slovenia 11 11 11 11
Macedonia, FYR 11 11 11 11
Thailand 11 11 11 10
Netherlands 11 11 11 11
Canada 11 11 11 11
Czech Republic 11 11 10 10
Slovak Republic 11 11 11 10
Virgin Islands (U.S.) 12 11 11 11
Puerto Rico 12 11 11 11
Finland 11 11 11 11
Belarus 11 11 12 12
Denmark 11 11 11 10
Lithuania 12 12 11 10
Luxembourg 11 12 11 11
Cyprus 12 12 12 12
Qatar 12 12 11 11
Mauritius 12 12 11 11
Estonia 12 12 11 11
Belgium 12 12 12 11
China 12 12 12 12
Montenegro 12 12 12 12
Bermuda 12 12 12 12
Sweden 12 12 12 12
Moldova 12 12 12 12
Russian Federation 12 13 13 13
Hong Kong SAR, China 12 13 14 13
Norway 13 13 12 12
Albania 13 13 13 13
Lebanon 13 13 13 13
Barbados 13 13 13 13
France 13 13 13 13
United Kingdom 13 13 13 13
United States 14 13 13 13
Dominica 13
Curacao 13 14 13 13
Australia 14 14 14 14
Georgia 14 14 14 14
Armenia 14 14 14 14
Chile 14 14 14 14
Korea, Dem. Rep. 14 14 14 14
New Zealand 14 15 14 14
Uruguay 15 15 15 15
Cayman Islands 16 15 15 13
Jamaica 16 15 15 15
Trinidad and Tobago 15 15 15 15
Greenland 16 15 14 14
Iceland 16 15 14 14
Bahamas, The 16 16 15 15
Brazil 16 16 15 15
Costa Rica 16 16 16 15
United Arab Emirates 16 16 16 15
Bahrain 17 16 16 16
St. Lucia 17 16 16 16
Vietnam 17 16 16 16
Ireland 17 17 16 16
New Caledonia 16 17 16 16
Brunei Darussalam 17 17 16 16
Seychelles 18 17 19 19
St. Martin (French part) 17 17 17 16
Antigua and Barbuda 17 17 17 17
French Polynesia 17 17 17 17
St. Vincent and the Grenadines 17 17 17 17
Argentina 17 17 17 17
Malaysia 18 18 18 18
Turkey 18 18 17 17
Guam 18 18 18 17
Myanmar 18 18 18 17
Azerbaijan 17 18 19 19
Suriname 19 18 18 18
Sri Lanka 19 18 18 18
Kosovo 19 19 18 18
Tunisia 18 19 19 19
American Samoa 19
Iran, Islamic Rep. 19 19 19 19
Grenada 19 19 19 19
Mexico 20 20 19 19
Colombia 20 20 19 19
Indonesia 20 20 20 19
Panama 21 20 20 20
El Salvador 21 20 20 20
Bhutan 21 21 20 20
Peru 21 21 20 20
Venezuela, RB 21 21 20 20
Saudi Arabia 21 21 20 20
Cabo Verde 21 21 21 20
Bangladesh 21 21 21 20
India 22 21 21 21
Kuwait 21 21 21 21
South Africa 22 22 21 21
Fiji 22 22 21 21
Guyana 22 22 21 21
Oman 22 22 22 21
Ecuador 22 22 21 21
Turkmenistan 22 22 22 22
Israel 22 22 21 22
Morocco 21 22 22 23
Dominican Republic 22 22 22 21
Libya 22 22 22 21
Maldives 22 22 22 22
Kazakhstan 22 23 23 23
Uzbekistan 23 23 22 21
Mongolia 23 23 23 23
Nepal 24 23 22 22
Kiribati 24 23 23 23
Micronesia, Fed. Sts. 24 24 24 24
Nicaragua 24 24 24 23
Egypt, Arab Rep. 24 24 24 24
Paraguay 25 24 24 24
Botswana 25 24 24 24
Belize 25 24 24 24
Algeria 24 25 25 25
Syrian Arab Republic 25 25 25 24
Philippines 25 25 25 25
Cambodia 26 26 26 26
Bolivia 27 26 26 26
Pakistan 27 27 26 26
Haiti 27 27 26 26
Kyrgyz Republic 25 27 27 28
Honduras 27 27 26 26
Namibia 27 27 27 26
Tonga 28 27 27 26
Vanuatu 28 27 27 27
Lesotho 28 28 28 28
Samoa 28 28 27 27
Lao PDR 29 28 28 27
Djibouti 29 28 28 28
Jordan 29 29 28 28
Papua New Guinea 31 30 30 29
Swaziland 31 31 31 30
West Bank and Gaza 32 31 31 31
Zimbabwe 32 32 32 32
Guatemala 33 32 32 31
Ghana 33 32 32 31
Yemen, Rep. 33 32 32 31
Iraq 33 32 32 31
Tajikistan 32 33 33 33
Gabon 33 33 32 32
Solomon Islands 33 33 32 31
Fragile and conflict affected situations 35 34 34 34
Ethiopia 35 35 34 34
Sudan 35 35 34 34
Central African Republic 35 35 35 34
Mauritania 36 35 35 34
Madagascar 36 35 35 35
Sao Tome and Principe 37 36 36 35
Timor-Leste 37 36 36 36
Cote d'Ivoire 36 37 37 37
Equatorial Guinea 37 37 36 36
Kenya 37 37 36 36
Rwanda 37 37 36 36
Comoros 38 37 36 36
Liberia 38 37 37 36
South Sudan 38 37 37 37
Togo 38 37 37 37
Benin 38 38 37 37
Afghanistan 39 38 37 35
Guinea 39 38 38 37
Sierra Leone 39 38 38 37
Eritrea 39 38 38 37
Senegal 39 39 38 38
Guinea-Bissau 39 39 38 38
Cameroon 39 39 38 38
Congo, Rep. 39 39 38 38
Tanzania 41 41 40 40
Mozambique 41 41 40 39
Malawi 41 41 40 40
Nigeria 42 42 42 42
Burkina Faso 43 43 42 41
Zambia 43 43 43 43
Gambia, The 43 43 43 43
Congo, Dem. Rep. 44 44 44 43
Uganda 45 45 44 44
Somalia 46 45 45 44
Burundi 45 45 45 45
Angola 47 46 46 45
Chad 48 47 47 46
Mali 48 48 48 47
Niger 50 50 50 50
Faeroe Islands 12 13
Monaco
St. Kitts and Nevis
Palau
Turks and Caicos Islands
Tuvalu
Northern Mariana Islands
Isle of Man
Sint Maarten (Dutch part)
Marshall Islands

Featured indicators

Help/Feedback

User Voice